Landlord guides and kits · instant download
Shop

Home / Free property tools / Fine check

Free property tool

Rent repayment order check: how much could a tribunal make you pay back?

A landlord who breaks certain housing rules can be ordered to repay rent to the tenant or the council. It is called a rent repayment order. It is not called a fine, but it costs like one. This check compares your position with 512 real orders made in England.

Fine check

What tribunals really ordered landlords to pay back

For offences committed on or after 1 May 2026, a tribunal can order up to 2 years' rent. For earlier offences the limit is 12 months' rent. We read 814 published decisions from 1 January 2023 to 3 November 2026. In the 673 where we could read the result, 76 in 100 ended with an order, and the typical order was £6,082.

Enter the rent, what went wrong and for how long. You will see the most a tribunal could order, what share of the rent tribunals really ordered in cases like yours, and the real orders behind the figures, each linked to the original on GOV.UK.

The sums are done on your own phone or computer. Nothing you type in the check is sent unless you choose to send it to Stephen below.

General information for England, not legal advice. A past decision does not predict yours: every case is decided on its own facts.

All twenty free tools

Worried about a fine or a rent repayment order?

Ask Stephen to call you back and he will tell you what to put right first. If you would rather hand it over, full management keeps licences, certificates and deposit paperwork on track for you.

SYND Properties is run by Stephen Yeboah, director of SYND LTD (company 14617841). SYND LTD is a member of Property Redress (no. PRS044043) and registered with the Information Commissioner’s Office (no. ZB517777). Read our Google reviews.

First: does the home need a licence?

Most orders are about a missing licence. Two questions give you the national rule. Your council may add its own.

What share of the rent tribunals ordered back

These orders were made under the rules before 1 May 2026, when the most a tribunal could order was 12 months' rent. For anything done on or after 1 May 2026 the limit is 2 years' rent, so future orders can be larger.

How a tribunal settles the figure

  1. Rent paid. It starts with the rent the tenant paid in the period, less any paid by Universal Credit or Housing Benefit.
  2. Bills taken off. Gas, electricity and similar bills included in the rent usually come off.
  3. How serious. It sets a share of the rent to match how serious the breach was.
  4. Conduct and means. It moves the figure for how landlord and tenant behaved, the landlord's finances and any earlier conviction. For things done on or after 1 May 2026, earlier penalties and earlier rent repayment orders also count.

What went with bigger orders

75% v 65%share of rent ordered where the decision says the landlord did not attend the hearing (65 orders), against the rest
70% v 60%where the decision mentions damp, mould or disrepair (187 orders), against the rest

These are patterns in what the decisions say, not proof of cause. They point the same way as the law: condition of the home and how the landlord behaves both count.

Real orders

DecidedAreaWhat went wrongOrdered to repayShare of rent

Each date links to the published decision on GOV.UK. Figures are read from the decisions by software and may contain errors, so check the original before you rely on one.

What can lead to an order

GOV.UK lists ten things. The first two are behind most of the orders we read.

  1. Running a shared house (HMO) that needs a licence without one
  2. Letting a home without a licence in an area where the council requires one
  3. Not doing what an improvement notice says
  4. Not doing what a prohibition order says
  5. Illegal eviction or harassment
  6. Using or threatening violence to get into a home
  7. Breaking a banning order
  8. Knowingly or recklessly misusing a ground for possession
  9. Letting or marketing a home within 12 months of using the "moving in" or "selling" ground
  10. Continuing to break certain of the new tenancy rules

For offences committed on or after 1 May 2026, a tribunal can order up to 2 years' rent. For earlier offences the limit is 12 months' rent. An order can be made against the landlord. For things done on or after 1 May 2026, it can also be made against a landlord higher up the chain, or a director of a company landlord who agreed to the offence or let it happen through neglect, and a tenant or council can apply up to 2 years afterwards. For things done on or after 1 May 2026, the tribunal must order the maximum if the landlord was convicted of the offence, or given a penalty for it that can no longer be appealed, unless the case is exceptional. Source: GOV.UK, "Rent repayment orders: guidance for local authorities".

Ask Stephen to look at your home

Tell us the postcode and what worries you. Stephen will reply himself, usually the same working day. It costs nothing to ask.

We use your details, and your answers if you tick the box, only to reply to you. We keep them for up to 12 months. See our privacy notice.

Questions

Where do the figures come from?

From decisions of the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) published on GOV.UK, decided from 1 January 2023 to 3 November 2026. We read 814 decisions. In 673 we could read the result: 512 ended with an order and 161 did not. Each row links to the original. We do not store anyone's name.

How do I know if my home needs a licence?

Rules differ from council to council. A shared house with 5 or more people from 2 or more households needs a licence everywhere in England. Many councils also license smaller shared houses, and some license every rented home in certain streets. Ask your council, or ask us and we will check for you.

What if the rent was paid by Universal Credit or Housing Benefit?

The tenant can claim back rent paid by them or for them, but not the part paid by Universal Credit or Housing Benefit. The council can apply for that part.

Can I lower the risk now?

If a licence is needed, apply for it straight away: the breach normally stops once a full application is made. Fix any hazards, keep your records, and if a claim is made, take part in the hearing. Then get advice on your own case.

Is this legal advice?

No. It is general information for England to help you see the size of the risk. Every case is decided on its own facts, and a past decision does not predict yours.

Does it cover Wales, Scotland or Northern Ireland?

No. England only.

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0. Source: First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) decisions published on GOV.UK, decided from 1 January 2023 to 3 November 2026. Figures are read from the published decisions by software and may contain errors; each row links to the original.

WhatsApp Stephen Call Stephen Free valuation